- Local time
- Today, 03:45
- Joined
- Feb 28, 2001
- Messages
- 29,011
This is an interesting development.
In essence, the arbitration unit on sports competition issues ruled against a trans athlete - but chose a path that didn't rule against one of the "open competition" regulations for international swimming. The decision was a "lacks standing" response - unanimous - and I can't find something that may have been removed after the first time I saw the article. I can't find it now, but someone raised the argument that trans person Lia Thomas was disqualified because she did not go through puberty as a woman, so all those hormonal advantages kicked in before she went trans.
There is some talk about setting up a third competition category - now not only men's and women's events - but an "open" event that doesn't care about your currently perceived gender.
Transgender swimmer Lia Thomas loses legal challenge in CAS ruling
The CAS panel found that 'for the time being' Lia Thomas is not eligible to compete in elite competitions through World Aquatics or USA Swimming.
sports.yahoo.com
In essence, the arbitration unit on sports competition issues ruled against a trans athlete - but chose a path that didn't rule against one of the "open competition" regulations for international swimming. The decision was a "lacks standing" response - unanimous - and I can't find something that may have been removed after the first time I saw the article. I can't find it now, but someone raised the argument that trans person Lia Thomas was disqualified because she did not go through puberty as a woman, so all those hormonal advantages kicked in before she went trans.
There is some talk about setting up a third competition category - now not only men's and women's events - but an "open" event that doesn't care about your currently perceived gender.